ClubRightHelp centre Open ClubRight

A member has been charged twice

How to spot, check and refund a duplicate charge in ClubRight, and the common causes.

Occasionally a member is charged twice for the same membership in a short window. This article explains how to check for a duplicate, what usually causes one, and how to refund the duplicate.

How to check for a duplicate charge

Check the member's payment schedule.

  1. Go to Contacts and open the member.

  2. On their membership, click Manage & view details, then click View full schedule.

  3. Look for two payments showing Success for the same period. They're normally on the same day or very close together, for the same amount.

  4. If the member has more than one membership on their profile, check each one's schedule too. Each active membership collects on its own schedule.

Common causes

  • Manual collection after an automatic retry succeeded. ClubRight Pay automatically reattempts failed Direct Debits. If a staff member also takes payment manually through the till, both can succeed.

  • Two active memberships. The member has been put onto a second active membership without the first being cancelled, so both collect on schedule. If it was added twice but only paid once, see "A payment shows twice but I only took it once" below.

  • Joining fee plus regular payment on the same day. When a joining fee or pro-rata payment lands on the same date as the first regular collection, this can look like a duplicate even though both are separately valid.

  • Two payment methods on the same membership. If both Direct Debit and card are set up and both collect, the member is charged twice.

A failed Direct Debit and a till payment on the same day

If a member's Direct Debit failed and they then paid at the till on the same day, that is one charge, not two. A failed payment takes no money, so the till payment is the only money taken, even though both appear on the member's schedule.

A real double charge is two successful payments for the same period. Check the status of each payment on the member's schedule before refunding anything.

A payment shows twice but I only took it once

If the membership was added twice and the payment was recorded at the till both times, refund the extra sale and cancel the extra membership. This corrects your records. No money moves, so don't refund the member on your card machine.

  1. Go to Contacts and open the member.

  2. Open Purchases and click the extra sale.

  3. Click Refund sale, then Yes. The payment on that membership changes to Refunded, and the sale comes out of your Till History totals.

  4. Cancel the extra membership.

You can do steps 3 and 4 in either order. Refund sale still shows after the membership is cancelled.

If the payment was taken on a ClubRight Pay card terminal, Refund sale does send the money back to the card. If it really was taken twice, follow "How to refund the duplicate" below.

When you add a plan the member already has, ClubRight warns They already have this. Click Cancel unless you really mean to add a second one.

How to refund the duplicate

  1. In the member's schedule, find the duplicate payment.

  2. Refund it. The steps depend on how it was paid:

    • ClubRight Pay Direct Debit: click the refund (bin) icon next to it, choose a refund reason and click Refund.

    • Card (ClubRight Pay Card or Stripe): click the Refund payment button next to it (a curved arrow, not a bin), then Yes, refund it.

    • GoCardless Direct Debit: a collected GoCardless payment has no refund button, so refund it from your GoCardless account or by bank transfer.

  3. If the cause was a second active membership or two payment methods on the same membership, fix that so it doesn't happen again.

For the full refund process, including timing rules for Direct Debit, see Refunding a member: process and rules.

Talking to the member

A double charge is usually visible on the member's bank statement before they call you. Acknowledge that the duplicate happened, confirm you have refunded it, and explain the timing: card refunds typically return within a few days, Direct Debit refunds within seven.

Helpful tip

💡 Check for a retry before taking payment another way. If a member's Direct Debit has failed, check their schedule for a retry that's already waiting before you take the money at the till. If both go through, the member is charged twice. See "Can I stop a reattempt and take payment another way?" in Why has a member's Direct Debit failed?

Have more questions about duplicate charges?

If you have a question that is not covered here, our Customer Success team is happy to help. Reach out via the chat button at the bottom right of your ClubRight dashboard.

Related help articles