When a membership is frozen, scheduled payments should not be collected. If a frozen member has been charged, this article explains how to check what was charged, how to refund the charge, and how to make sure it does not happen again.
How to check what was charged
Check the member's payment schedule.
Go to Contacts and open the member.
On the frozen membership, click Manage & view details, then click View full schedule.
Look for a payment showing Success with a date inside the freeze, and compare it with the freeze dates on the membership.
If the member has more than one membership on their profile, check each one's schedule. Only the frozen one stops collecting.
How this usually happens
The freeze was set up after the next collection had already been scheduled. Direct Debit collections are requested several working days in advance. If the freeze is added inside that window, the collection has already left ClubRight and will go ahead.
The freeze From date is after the collection date. The freeze starts after the charge, so the charge is valid as configured even though it happened during what the member thinks is their freeze period.
The freeze Until date is open-ended or missing. Worth checking the configuration even if this is not the cause of the specific charge, because it will affect future cycles.
The member has a second active membership. Only one membership is frozen. The other continues to collect.
How to fix it
Go to Contacts and open the member.
On the membership, click Manage & view details, then click View full schedule.
Locate the dated payment showing Success that should not have been collected.
Refund it. For a ClubRight Pay Direct Debit payment, click the refund (bin) icon, choose a refund reason and click Refund. For a card payment, click the Refund payment button (a curved arrow), then Yes, refund it. A collected GoCardless payment has no refund button, so refund it from your GoCardless account or by bank transfer.
Check the freeze configuration on the membership. Make sure the freeze dates cover the period the member expected, and check whether any other active memberships are still collecting.
For the full refund process, see Refunding a member: process and rules. For freezing memberships in detail, see Freezing, unfreezing and pausing memberships.
Talking to the member
A charge during a freeze is one of the easiest types of dispute to handle: confirm the freeze should have prevented it, refund the charge, and explain why it happened in plain terms (most commonly "the collection was already with your bank before the freeze took effect"). If the freeze configuration was incorrect, acknowledge that too and confirm what you have changed.
Helpful tip
💡 Set freezes well before the next collection date. Direct Debit collections are requested several working days ahead. Setting a freeze at least a week before the next scheduled payment avoids the most common cause of a frozen member being charged.
Have more questions about freeze charges?
If you have a question that is not covered here, our Customer Success team is happy to help. Reach out via the chat button at the bottom right of your ClubRight dashboard.