ClubRightHelp centre Open ClubRight

Troubleshooting overdue members

Why members become overdue, how to spot them in ClubRight, and how to collect the missed payment.

A member becomes overdue when a scheduled payment has not been collected and there is no replacement payment in place. This article explains the common reasons a member can become overdue, how to find them in ClubRight, and how to collect the missing payment.


Finding overdue members

ClubRight surfaces overdue members in four places:

  • The Overdue tile on your dashboards, which shows the current count of members with overdue or failed payments.

  • Dashboard notifications. A new notification appears when a payment fails or a mandate is cancelled.

  • The Payments area. The Debtors section shows all members with overdue balances in one place, which is the best view for working through them in bulk. See Working with the Payments area in ClubRight.

  • Unpaid in Contacts. In Contacts > All Members, click Unpaid under Status to see every overdue member alongside the rest of their record.

Why does the dashboard Overdue number differ from Unpaid in Contacts?

They're the same members under two names, but the dashboard only counts plans set to show in dashboard stats, and it updates about every 5 minutes.

  • Plans left out of the dashboard. The Overdue tile only counts members on plans with Include in Dashboard Stats switched on (on the plan's edit page). Unpaid in Contacts counts overdue members on every plan, so it can be higher.

  • Timing. The dashboard number is worked out about every 5 minutes. Unpaid is counted when you open the page, so straight after a payment fails or is taken, the two can differ for a few minutes.

If the numbers still don't match after 5 minutes, click the chat button to talk to our Customer Success team.


Common reasons a member is overdue

There are six common reasons a member's account shows as overdue. Working through them in order is the fastest way to identify what has happened.

1. The scheduled payment failed

The most common cause. The member's Direct Debit or card payment was rejected by their bank, usually due to insufficient funds, a cancelled mandate, or an expired card. To see the failure reason, open the member's profile and view their payment schedule. Failed payments are marked Failed Refer to Payer or similar.

For more on Direct Debit failures specifically, see Why has a member's Direct Debit failed?. For card payment failures, see Why can't my member pay by card online?.

2. The member cancelled their stored payment method

If the member has cancelled their Direct Debit mandate at their bank, or removed their stored card, scheduled payments cannot be collected. On the member's profile, the Payments view will show no active mandate or no stored card.

3. The plan was set up too close to the payment date

Both Direct Debit providers, ClubRight Pay and GoCardless, need six working days before the first payment can be taken.

If a member signed up too close to their first payment date, the first collection will not happen on time, and the member becomes overdue until you take the payment manually or wait for the next scheduled collection.

4. A joining fee or pro-rata payment is outstanding

Joining fees and pro-rata payments are always charged upfront at sign-up and need to be collected manually if they did not go through at the point of joining. These appear as overdue lines on the member's profile until you collect them.

5. No payment method is set up on the membership

If the membership was created without a payment method (for example by importing or manually adding a member), scheduled collections cannot be set up. To add one, open the member's membership and click the payment option to add a Direct Debit mandate or card.

6. A requested payment was cancelled

If a Direct Debit collection was requested and then cancelled, it shows as failed in ClubRight. If you re-request it for after the original payment date, the member will be overdue from the original date until the new collection completes. For example, a payment due on the 1st that is re-requested on the 3rd will leave the member overdue between those two dates.


How to collect an overdue payment

Once you have identified the cause, there are three ways to collect the missing payment.

In-club, through the till

  1. Open the member's profile from Contacts.

  2. On the overdue membership tile, click Collect.

  3. Click Take payment.

  4. If the member has a card saved, you can click Charge £… to card ending …. Otherwise click Pay another way (go to till), or Go to till if no card is saved.

  5. Choose how the member is paying, for example Cash or Card terminal (PDQ), and finish taking the payment. The till shows Payment recorded when it's done.

The member is immediately brought back up to date.

A member paid on our card machine instead of by Direct Debit. How do I record it?

Take the overdue payment at the till and choose Card terminal (PDQ). This records money already taken on your card machine without charging the member again.

  1. Open the member's profile from Contacts.

  2. On the overdue membership tile, click Collect, then Take payment.

  3. Click Go to till (or Pay another way (go to till) if they have a card saved).

  4. Choose Card terminal (PDQ) and finish. The member is brought back up to date straight away.

If a Direct Debit retry for the same amount is already with the bank, Take payment only offers what isn't already being collected (see "If a Direct Debit retry is already booked" below).

Can I collect an overdue payment by Direct Debit?

Yes, if the member has a ClubRight Pay or GoCardless Direct Debit set up. Click Collect by DD on the membership, and ClubRight books a one-off Direct Debit for the overdue amount.

  1. Open the member's profile from Contacts.

  2. On the overdue membership tile, click Manage & view details.

  3. Click Collect by DD, next to Take payment.

There's no "are you sure?" step: the collection is booked straight away and ClubRight shows "One-off direct debit of £… scheduled." It's taken on the earliest date the Direct Debit provider allows, so never the same day.

If the member's last payment didn't fail, they stop showing as overdue as soon as the collection is booked. If their last payment failed, they stay overdue until the new collection is paid.

Collect by DD doesn't show:

  • on a membership that hasn't started yet

  • while a collection is already with the bank. The membership says A re-try has already been requested if the member is overdue, or A collection is already in progress if not.

GoCardless: when you click Collect by DD, ClubRight checks with GoCardless first:

  • If GoCardless is already collecting a payment (a monthly payment or a retry), nothing extra is taken, and you're shown how much is on its way and when. ClubRight adds that payment to the member's record, so the month stops showing as owed.

  • If GoCardless is waiting for the member to approve their payments, nothing is taken. Ask the member to approve, or take payment at the till.

  • If GoCardless can't be reached, nothing is taken. Try again in a few minutes.

Add to DD on Payments > Debtors shows the same messages.

Why can't I see Schedule one-off DD for a new member?

For a new member whose first Direct Debit can't be taken in time, the button is called Schedule one-off DD, under "This amount needs to be collected separately". It only shows when:

  • the membership is paid by Direct Debit

  • the membership has started. It doesn't show while the membership says Starting soon.

  • the member has a Direct Debit set up with your club's provider (ClubRight Pay or GoCardless). Check the Payment Methods card on their profile.

Take payment always shows beside it, so if the button is missing, take the money at the till instead.

You can also collect by Direct Debit from Collect DD on the member quick view (it asks "Collect by Direct Debit?", then Yes, collect now), from Add to DD on Payments > Debtors, or from Collect £… by Direct Debit on the Unpaid list's Collect panel.

How do I stop a Direct Debit payment before it's taken?

You can only stop a payment that's still showing Requested with a bin icon. Once it's been sent to the bank, the bin goes and N/A shows instead, and it can't be stopped from ClubRight. If that happens, refund the member once the payment has gone through.

  1. Open the member's profile and click Manage & view details on the membership.

  2. Click View full schedule.

  3. Next to the payment showing Requested, click the bin icon, then Yes, delete it.

The payment then shows as Failed with the note Cancelled, and the amount is owed again, so the membership shows as overdue. Refresh the page if it doesn't update straight away. Take the payment another way, or book it again with Collect by DD.

I took a payment at the till. Why is the failed payment still red?

A month shows in red as MISSED when ClubRight still counts it as unpaid. A till payment is put against the oldest unpaid month first, not the month you took it for. So if the member owed for more than one month, a later month can still show red after they've paid cash or card at the till.

There's no way to link a till payment to one specific overdue payment or mark off a particular month. When you pay off an overdue balance, the payment always clears the oldest amount owed first. Check DUE on the membership to see what's still owed (see below).

Paying off the overdue balance vs an ordinary till sale

Only a Membership payment line in the till pays off what the member owes. You get this line when you take payment from the overdue membership (see the steps above). It's also added automatically when you click Sell on the member's profile.

If you remove that line and ring up a product instead, the money is recorded as a sale but nothing comes off the membership. This applies even to a product set up for membership payments, and even when the amount matches. The member stays overdue and stays on Payments > Debtors. If this has already happened, contact our Customer Success team.

What the member's payments look like afterwards

Open the membership and click Manage & view details. The Schedule shows each month as:

  • PAID (green): covered, either by the Direct Debit or by a till payment. A month whose Direct Debit failed shows as PAID once a till payment has covered it.

  • COLLECTING (amber): a collection or retry has been sent to the bank and hasn't cleared yet.

  • MISSED (red): still unpaid.

Click View full schedule to see every transaction. Failed Direct Debit collections stay listed there as Failed, for example Failed Refer to Payer. Till payments appear as separate Sale rows with the status Success. The Due column shows what's still owed after each row.

How to tell what the member still owes

  1. Open the member's profile from Contacts.

  2. Check the membership tile. A paid-up membership shows Payments up to date instead of an overdue amount and Collect.

  3. Click Manage & view details and check DUE. Anything above £0.00 is still owed, and the red months show which ones.

  4. To see where each payment went, click View full schedule and look at the Due column after each Sale row.

💡 Tip: If a member pays at the till for a particular month and an earlier month is still unpaid, the payment clears the earlier month. Check DUE before you tell the member they're up to date.

If a Direct Debit retry is already booked

If the retry hasn't gone to the bank yet (there's a bin icon next to the pending payment on the member's profile), the amount being retried shows as PENDING, not DUE, so Take payment has nothing to offer for it. Cancel the retry first, then take the payment or write it off. See "If Take payment isn't showing" in How do I clear or write off a member's debt?.

While a retry is with the bank, the membership shows A re-try has already been requested. In the Schedule, that month shows as COLLECTING. You can still take payment, but Take payment only offers the amount that isn't already being collected, so the member isn't charged twice for the same payment. If the retry then fails, the month goes back to MISSED and you can collect it.

For cancelling a retry and taking the payment another way instead, see Why has a member's Direct Debit failed?

Can I delete a missed payment?

No. You can't delete or remove a missed or failed payment from a member's payment schedule. To clear what they owe without taking money, write it off at the till instead. The month then shows as PAID, the member is no longer overdue, and they come off Payments > Debtors. See How do I clear or write off a member's debt?

A failed Direct Debit collection stays listed in View full schedule as Failed, with the write-off shown as a separate Sale row.

If the payment hasn't been taken yet, for example a Direct Debit still showing as Requested, wait for the result before writing anything off, because the bank may still collect it.

Online, by the member themselves

When an overdue member logs into the ClubRight Member App or your member area, they are automatically prompted to clear the outstanding balance. They can pay by card on the spot, without staff involvement.

For this to work, you need ClubRight Pay Card connected. See Why can't my member pay by card online? for setup checks.


Can an overdue member still check in?

No. While any of a member's memberships is overdue, the Welcome Screen and the Check in button on their profile both turn them away with "There are outstanding membership fees due on your membership, please chat to a member of staff". Once you take the overdue payment, they can get in. For the other reasons a member can be turned away, see Why was a member refused entry on the welcome screen?


Automated chasing

ClubRight can automatically chase overdue members with a sequence of escalating reminders, so your team only has to step in for the cases that need human follow-up. See Chasing overdue payments with Smart Workflows.

Automated chasing uses Smart Workflows, which is part of the ClubRight Complete package. On Core, chase overdue members by hand: use the Debtors section of the Payments area (see "Finding overdue members") and the steps in "How to collect an overdue payment" above.

Can I stop overdue emails sending at weekends or on bank holidays?

No. Nothing in ClubRight holds messages back on certain days of the week or on bank holidays, in message automations or in Smart Workflows. A delay counts calendar days, including weekends and bank holidays, from when the member is marked overdue. So a 3-day delay (Days after) on someone marked overdue on a Friday sends on the Monday.

A delay still works well as a buffer. If the member's overdue amount is cleared before the email is due, ClubRight cancels it and they never get it. To control the time of day messages go out, use When should messages go out? under Settings > Messaging.


Helpful tip

💡 Try the self-serve path first. Members logging in to the app see an overdue prompt automatically. Many will clear the balance themselves before you ever need to phone them. Automated reminders give them the nudge to do so.


Have more questions about overdue members?

If you have a question that is not covered here, our Customer Success team is happy to help. Reach out via the chat button at the bottom right of your ClubRight dashboard.


Related help articles